Caste-based discrimination in India was codified into regulation in 1871 by the British colonial authorities after they enacted the Legal Tribes Act branding a number of nomadic and indigenous communities as “hereditary criminals” – criminals by delivery, enforced by the establishment of policing. Although this regulation was repealed in 1952, the devastating taint of criminality for these “Denotified Tribes” (DNTs or “Vimukta”) has persevered by imprecise legal guidelines and caste-based policing. Lawyer and social entrepreneur Nikita Sonavane co-founded the Criminal Justice and Police Accountability Project in Bhopal, India to finish the disproportionate concentrating on of oppressed caste communities by the legal justice system. Ashoka’s Angelou Ezeilo sat down with Nikita to study extra.
Angelou Ezeilo: Nikita, your initiative, which goals to extend transparency in policing, is difficult some long-held types of discrimination in India. Might you give us a quick overview of your nation’s caste system?
Nikita Sonavane: Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, the founding father of our structure, referred to as it a system of graded inequality. On this system, occupation is assigned by delivery. First there are the Brahmins, the mental class; then the Kshatriyas, the warrior caste; then the Vaishyas, the service provider class. On the backside of it are the Shudras, the “menial” laborers. After which, after all, there are communities who fall exterior of the caste system, such because the Denotified Tribes, who’re deemed criminal at birth. As soon as you might be born right into a caste group, you are solely allowed to affiliate with individuals belonging to that caste. Any type of intermixing is a violation.
Ezeilo: Thanks for that, Nikita. As an African American girl, it’s onerous for me not to attract parallels between the laws criminalizing sure tribes in India and the Jim Crow legal guidelines of the American South—and in each circumstances, police discrimination has continued lengthy after these legal guidelines have been repealed. What impressed you to do that work? As a result of it isn’t snug work to be doing.
Sonavane: No, in no way. However for me, doing this work is a approach to make sense of my lived expertise. I belong to a group often called the Dalits, or “untouchables”. I keep in mind engaged on a mission in regulation college that mapped the socio-economic profiles of demise row convicts in India and seeing that almost all of those individuals have been Dalits. I grew to become curious: why are solely sure sorts of individuals ending up on demise row? Why is a sure set of individuals disproportionately incarcerated?
Ezeilo: This concept of hereditary criminality is deeply disturbing, but we’re seeing it play out in each of our communities. Inform me, how do the police present up in your work?
Sonavane: Police are the primary level of contact within the legal justice system. They resolve who’s arrested and who leads to jail. So, I used to be very fascinated about how and why they have been exercising these discretionary powers.
To zoom out for a second: one recurring critique of the Indian legal justice system is that it is a colonial physique. It’s a critique that has allowed us to position the British on the root of the issue. However it’s clear that the story predates the British. The caste system, which existed lengthy earlier than they arrived, was the fertile floor upon which they constructed their discriminatory authorized system and the establishment of policing.
Many are actually calling for police reforms. However once we have a look at the origin of the police, we see that its normal working process is to keep up caste hierarchy by maintaining the “low castes” of their place. So, to me, it’s absurd to be speaking about reforming the police with out speaking about dismantling the caste system.
Ezeilo: So many parallels to the U.S. Now, I’m actually fascinated about your deal with girls in marginalized communities and the hazard they face in police custody. Please speak to me about this time period, “custodial rape”.
Sonavane: Indian regulation outlined “custodial rape” approach again within the early Eighties as sexual violence in police custody by police personnel. The time period emerged when two policemen raped a minor lady from a tribal group (also called “Adivasi”) whereas she was in custody. After all, the Supreme Court docket acquitted them.
I am immediately drawn to a parallel, Angelou, out of your context: the way in which that Black feminists first challenged the concept of a monolithic “womanhood.” Right here we’re combating to indicate that girls who belong to tribal communities are experiencing violence as tribal girls, not simply as girls. When Denotified tribal girls, for instance, are on the receiving finish of police violence, it’s argued that they’re mendacity as a way to cover the crime that they’ve dedicated. Deeming these girls ‘legal’ is a approach to cover and even excuse the hurt performed to them, in a approach that may by no means occur to higher-caste girls.
Ezeilo: Nikita, are you able to inform us about how massive tech appears to be reinforcing this method of caste discrimination?
Sonavane: It’s occurring within the American legal justice system, as effectively, proper? The police are constructing these big databases, digitizing the legal data of various individuals, and pushing for predictive policing that can decide who’s extra prone to be committing a criminal offense. Saying that know-how goes to make policing impartial is an entire hoax, as a result of the bias in policing is not only occurring on a person degree. It is structural. And know-how is just digitizing that.
Ezeilo: Proper, it’s accelerating a flawed system. Nikita, inform us why your group is supporting the authorized schooling of two college students from the Denotified group.
Sonavane: Having attorneys from our personal group could be very, crucial for us. Coming from our background, we’re in a position to see the regulation as a product of the society that it was formulated in, and never the kind of goal instrument that many see it as. So, educating college students from the group who’ve traditionally been silenced is a approach to heart their voices within the authorized system. They may have the ability to take a system that inflicted violence on them for therefore lengthy and use it to pursue justice.
Ezeilo: Might you share a current case that you simply labored on, and the function that members of the Denotified tribes have performed in main change with you?
Sonavane: A current case that we labored on was a 14-year-old youngster from a Denotified tribal group who was focused by the police, and we managed to get him acquitted. There have been individuals from the group there each step of the way in which, documenting the time that he was being illegally detained and subjected to torture, and social employees serving to him to deal with the trauma of incarceration. It has been a vastly affirming expertise for us.
Ezeilo: Thanks a lot for that work. However earlier than we go, I’d prefer to ask, what offers you the vitality to proceed the work? What brings you pleasure?
Sonavane: I do not need my group to be seen solely as victims of oppression. Dr. Ambedkar, an important voice within the wrestle of oppressed castes, stated that that is in the end a wrestle for us to reclaim our humanity. And seeing our individuals maintain that house for one another, pushing one another to stay that type of well-rounded existence, brings me immense pleasure.
This interview has been condensed for size and readability.
You may comply with the Criminal Justice & Police Accountability Project on Twitter.